| [Back to Articles]
"Letter from Jerusalem: Forcing the End"
July 20, 1998, The
New Yorker
In the spring
of 1989, a Pentecostal preacher named Clyde Lott was thumbing through
the Bible, looking up all the references to cows. This wasn't so
odd, given that Lott is one of the leading cattle breeders in the
Southeast. At the time, he specialized in raising show cattle for
youngsters involved in 4-H clubs and the Future Farmers of America.
His office, in Canton, Mississippi, contains many ribbons, plaques,
and trophies, including awards for two national championships in
judging and showmanship. As it happens, the Old Testament is full
of references to cows and cattle; it is, after all, a history of
an agricultural people. When Lott turned to Numbers 19, he read
one of the many conversations that God had with Moses and his brother
Aaron as they led the Jews through the desert toward the Promised
Land. "Speak unto the children of Israel," the Lord commanded,
"that they bring thee a red heifer without spot, wherein is
no blemish, and upon which never came a yoke." The cow will
be given to a priest to slay, the Lord continued, and burned on
a pyre of cedar, hyssop, and a strand of scarlet thread. Then the
ashes of the heifer will be mixed with water and used to purify
those who have been exposed to death. Anyone who fails to be purified
"shall be cut off from among the congregation, because he hath
defiled the sanctuary of the Lord."
This is one
of the most mysterious injunctions in the Bible. Even King Solomon,
who was said to understand the meaning of all things, could not
explain the reason for the red heifer. Clyde Lott didn't understand
it, either. He also wondered where the children of Israel could
have obtained a red cow. From his own reading, he had concluded
that the Old Testament herd was descended from the cattle that Jacob,
the son of Isaac, had received in wages from his uncle Laban. Those
animals-as described in the King James Bible-were speckled, spotted,
and brown. "Your speckled and spotted cattle basically are
recognized as a purebred cow, like a holstein," Lott says.
So where did the spotless red heifer come from? Genetically, it
didn't add up. And yet the Lord had specified that this was the
only way for the Israelites to cleanse themselves and participate
in the worship of God. "I didn't realize then that God always
sent to Israel, at the time she needed it, the man with the red
heifer."
Lott, who is
forty-two, is a soft-spoken Southern gentleman, squarely built,
with a full, fleshy face and curly brown hair that is beginning
to gray. Although he is ordained in the ministry of the National
Pentecostal Assemblies of Jesus Christ, he does not pastor his own
church. "I would fit more in the category of evangelist-going
on the road and preaching or teaching," he says. Like all fundamentalist
Christians, Lott believes that the Messiah will come again. His
view of the End Time is that Jesus' return will usher in a thousand
years of peace and harmony. Before that, however, there will be
seven years of tribulation: the Antichrist will appear, and the
forces of good and evil will wage a cataclysmic struggle, culminating
in Jesus' defeat of the false Messiah. Many Evangelicals believe
that Jews and other non-Christians will suffer for accepting the
Antichrist as their messiah-that most of them will perish in the
coming struggle, but those who survive will finally acknowledge
Christ as their savior. True Christians will be spared these catastrophes,
because they will have been raptured-snatched directly into Heaven-before
the troubles begin. They will return to act as priests during Christ's
millennial reign. At the end of that time, Satan will rally the
forces of evil for a final confrontation with Jesus and the saints
of the Church at the battle of Armageddon. The satanic warriors,
led by a prince named Gog, will come from the north, from a land
called Magog (which Lott believes could be a satellite republic
of the former Soviet Union); God will destroy them, however. The
dead will rise for their day of judgment, and a New Jerusalem will
descend from the sky. Once again, God will dwell among his people.
A longing for
the rapture and the return of Jesus on Earth is at the core of Evangelicalism.
The fact that we are coincidentally approaching a millennial milestone
in the human calendar certainly adds to this yearning and to the
sense of anticipation felt by believers of all faiths. Most fundamentalists
assume that we are living on the edge of human history in any case,
and that modern events in the Middle East are fulfillments of prophecies
made some two thousand years ago by Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Isaiah, and
John, among others. These prophecies require three great events
before the Messiah can return: the nation of Israel must be restored;
Jerusalem must be a Jewish city; and the Temple, the center of worship
and sacrifice in the ancient Jewish world, which was last destroyed
by the Romans in 70 A.D., must be rebuilt. Two of these conditions
have been met in the last fifty years.
As Lott read
the Bible that day, he realized that the Second Coming and the fate
of humankind now depended on the red heifer. In order for the Jews
to rebuild the Temple and prepare the way for the return of the
Messiah they must be purified with the ashes of a red heifer.
A qualified
red heifer has not been found in Israel in almost two thousand years.
And yet red cattle are not really so unusual in the United States.
A breed known as the Red Angus is as red as an Irish setter. It
occurred to Lott that God, who he believed had directed the evangelist's
own success in the showring, was now guiding his hand in a much
larger matter. Where was the red heifer to come from? "That
was the question we couldn't answer," says Lott, who sometimes
uses the first-person plural when referring to himself. "It
plagued us day in and day out for months." Finally, in the
latter part of the summer of 1990, as he was baling hay, a piece
of equipment broke, and he started to drive into town to get a spare
part. But then he found himself driving to Jackson, the state capital,
and walking into the office of Roy D. Manning, the director of international
trade for the Mississippi Department of Agriculture and Commerce.
"I will
never forget as long as I live walking into Mr. Manning's office
that day and just the cold shock on his face of seeing someone coming
out of the hayfield-bluejeans, tennis shoes, baseball cap, dirty
and smelly-and walking into his office unannounced and saying, 'I
have read the Bible and the Bible says Israel has to have a red
heifer,'" Lott said later in one of many testimonials to Evangelical
congregations in the South. "For some reason, he didn't kick
me out of his office." Instead, Manning wrote a letter to an
attaché at the American Embassy in Athens who was in charge
of agricultural exports to the Middle East. "We have been approached
by a producer and seller of cattle from the state of Mississippi
and I am quoting him in the following," Manning wrote, and
the letter went on:
Red Angus cattle
suitable for Old Testament Biblical sacrifices, will have no blemish
or off color hair, genetically red will reproduce red, eye, nose
pigmentation will be dark, heifers at a year old will weigh approximately
600 to 700 pounds. These cattle will adapt quickly to Middle Eastern
climate, also excellent beef quality.
Manning's letter
was bounced to a State Department official, who rerouted it to the
American Embassy in Tel Aviv, where it was forwarded to the Israeli
Ministry of Religious Affairs. Someone there eventually thought
to send it to the Temple Institute, a private organization of religious
Jews in Jerusalem who suspect-like Lott-that the End Time may benearandare
dedicated to rebuilding the Temple. The letter arrived on the desk
of Rabbi Chaim Richman, ninety days after Manning posted it.
The Temple Institute
operates a small museum in the Jewish Quarter of the Old City. A
visitor steps down into a basement room that houses the collection
and a bookstore; one of the books on display is "The Mystery
of the Red Heifer: Divine Promise of Purity," by Rabbi Richman.
Also on display is a scale model of the sacrificial altar and replicas
of the decanters and lavers used in the Temple service. The flaxen
robes of the priests have been carefully reproduced, along with
the trumpets, harps, and lyres that the Levites are said to have
played in the courtyard of the Temple. "You woke up in the
morning to the sound of music from the Temple. You went to bed to
the sound of music from the Temple," a guide tells visitors.
"Any beautiful building you ever saw cannot compare with the
beauty of the Temple."
The goal of
the institute is not only to restore the Temple itself but to reinstate
the priestly castes, clerical rule, and animal sacrifice that characterized
the nation of Israel at the dawn of the Iron Age. To secular Israelis,
this sounds like a Jewish version of the Taliban. And yet the construction
of a third Temple is essential to the view that many Orthodox Jews
have of salvation and the coming of the Messiah. Without the Temple,
there is no way to fulfill many of the religious obligations, such
as ritual sacrifices, that the Torah requires. In Orthodox theology,
that means that all Jews are stuck in a state of impurity, and are
therefore unable to be in the presence of God. When a glass is broken
at a Jewish wedding, it is done in memory of the destruction of
the Temple. "The Holy Temple in Judaism is so important and
primary that it can really be said that Judaism as it is practiced
today is not the vehicle that God intended it to be," Richman
says. "The Prophets of Israel emphasize the fact that the Temple
is really much more than just a synagogue....The Temple is actually
the device through which God manifests His presence to mankind."
Naturally, the
name Lott caught the attention of the rabbis at the institute-and
not just because another Lott from Mississippi happens to be the
United States Senate Majority Leader. Genesis recounts the story
of Abraham's nephew Lot, whose wife became a pillar of salt when
she disobeyed the Lord and turned to look back on Sodom as it was
being destroyed. "Rabbi Richman told me that Lot was a Gentile
and he was a very, very good cattle breeder," Clyde Lott has
said. The rabbis thought that the coincidence was a good sign. After
an excited exchange of letters and telephone calls between Jerusalem
and Canton, Lott went to Jerusalem to meet with the rabbis. "I
really didn't know what to expect," he told me. "I came
out of a religious background that taught that Jewish people were
ignorant and lost, and this kind of thing." He was dazzled
by the Temple artifacts that the members of the institute had reconstructed.
"You can just imagine, having read all your adult life about
the Temple and the Tabernacle and the vessels, and seeing them firsthand-that
was amazing to me. It was a life-changing experience."
Lott tried to
explain his own beliefs to his hosts. "We talked about Jesus
and the Holy Spirit, and speaking in tongues. They knew where we
were coming from." The rabbis were impressed by Lott's sincerity.
"This is a person without guile," Richman, who was born
in America and immigrated to Israel in 1982, concluded. Richman
took Lott on a tour of the Western Wall and the Temple Mount. Over
the next several days, he gave the Pentecostal evangelist an education
in the Jewish oral tradition and the voluminous commentaries on
the enigmatic commandment of the red heifer. Jewish law, which is
called Halakah, maintains that all Jews today are impure because
of their direct or indirect contact with the dead. For that reason,
observant Jews may not go to parts of the Temple Mount, lest they
step on the Holy of Holies, the spot where the Ark of the Covenant
holding the fragments of the stone tablets containing the Ten Commandments
resided until it was supposedly lost during the Babylonians' destruction
of the First Temple, in 586 B.C. According to the rabbis, the only
way that Jews could become pure again was by being sprinkled with
the ashes of a red heifer that has been mixed with water traditionally
drawn from the pool of Siloam. According to the Mishnah, the written
version of the oral tradition, the ceremony of the red heifer sacrifice
has only been performed nine times in the history of the Jewish
people. When the tenth heifer appears, the Messiah will finally
come.
The rabbis,
for their part, learned something about cattle. Lott interpreted
the reference, in Numbers 19, to a cow without spot or blemish to
mean a good-milking, sweetly disposed, handsomely constructed animal-"basically,
a twenty-first-century, high-tech cow." Lott could see for
himself that the entire Israeli ranching industry was depressed
and behind the times. It occurred to him that with modern breeding
techniques and champion Red Angus stock he could produce not just
one red heifer but an entire herd.
As Lott likes
to tell Evangelical audiences, one of the rabbis wanted to know
how many red cows it would take to produce, in Israel, the kind
of heifer described by Numbers 19.
"Approximately
two hundred cows," Lott said.
"How much
per cow?"
"Of this
extremely high quality, about two thousand dollars a head."
When Richman
translated the figure into Hebrew, it caused a heated response among
the other rabbis. Lott asked what was wrong.
"Twenty
thousand a head is a lot of money," Richman said.
"We didn't
say twenty thousand, we said two thousand," Lott replied. "We're
not trying to take advantage of you as you seek to turn back to
God."
This response
brought expressions of amazement to the faces of the rabbis. Richman
explained to Lott that in the time of the Second Temple a jewel
from the breastplate of the high priest had fallen off. A delegation
of priests journeyed to the town of Ashkelon, to the house of a
well-known jeweller named Dama ben Netina. He agreed to replace
the jewel for a hundred shekels, but he said he could not do it
immediately, because the replacement was in a box that was under
the bed where his father was sleeping. The priests thought this
was merely a bargaining ploy and doubled the price. The jeweller
again refused. The priests continued to offer more money, and reached
the sum of a thousand shekels. But when the jeweller remained adamant
the delegation angrily started off on the road back to the Temple.
At last, the jeweller's father awakened. Dama ben Netina got the
jewel and raced after the delegation, catching up with it in a grove.
When a priest handed him a thousand shekels, the jeweller would
accept only the hundred that he had agreed to. "I am not trying
to take advantage of you as you are seeking to turn to God,"
he said.
When Lott heard
this story, he was deeply moved. "It was word for word the
same thing we said twenty-five hundred years later," he later
recalled. "Right there in that grove, they prayed a blessing
over Dama ben Netina, a Gentile, and the blessing was that out of
your Gentile lineage, one day when Israel needs it, will come the
producer of the red heifer."
In the fall
of 1994, Richman went to Mississippi to examine four freshly washed
and groomed heifers that Lott had produced for his inspection. The
Talmud states that even two hairs that are not red would be enough
to disqualify a candidate. One of the cows immediately caught Richman's
eye. "He didn't even look at the three others," Lott recalls.
"He walked into that pen with that heifer tied to the back
of that stall, and he just stopped for a few minutes to appraise
her from one end to the other. Then he walked right up to that heifer
within a matter of inches, and he looked down at her, then he went
back four or five feet and just stared at her." Finally, Richman
placed his hand on the animal, which Lott's daughter, who was then
six, had named Dixie. "This is the heifer that will change
the world," Richman said.
On June 7, 1967,
Israeli paratroopers dashed down the Via Dolorosa in the Old City
of Jerusalem. It was the third day of the Six-Day War. Jerusalem
had been until then a divided city, with Jordan in control of the
eastern half, including the Old City, and Israel in control of the
western half. This had been the status quo for nearly twenty years.
The 55th Parachute Brigade was about to change that.
And yet there
was a strange ambivalence on the part of many Israelis regarding
the taking of the Old City. Moshe Dayan, the Defense Minister, had
ordered General Uzi Narkiss to surround the Old City but not to
enter it. Dayan was worried not only about heavy casualties but
also about the political consequences of seizing the Temple Mount.
The rest of the Israeli Cabinet overruled him, however, and ordered
the retaking of the Old City.
The day before
the final battle, Israeli troops captured Mt. Scopus, the highest
point in the city. Dayan rode to the summit and lunched there with
General Narkiss. Dayan, who wore a black eye patch that covered
a wound he'd received fighting against the Vichy French in Syria,
personified Israeli military bravado. Before him were the honey-colored
limestone walls of the Old City. "What a divine view!"
Dayan, an avowedly secular man, declared. All around him, he could
see the hills of Golgotha, the Mount of Olives, Mt. Zion-names that
ring with meaning to believers of all three of the great monotheistic
religions. And in the middle of a bowl formed by limestone ridges
was the smaller elevation of Mt. Moriah, which Jews and Christians
call the Temple Mount, and which Muslims call Haram al-Sharif (the
Noble Sanctuary). It was here that King Solomon built the First
Temple, nearly a thousand years before the birth of Jesus. After
it was destroyed by Nebuchadrezzar, the Second Temple was built,
and was later expanded by King Herod into one of the greatest monuments
of the ancient world. The Romans destroyed it during their sacking
of Jerusalem. As Dayan looked down on the Temple Mount he realized
that the following morning it would be back in Jewish hands for
the first time in nearly two thousand years.
But what Dayan
also saw below him was a colossal political problem. The sacred
precinct was now occupied by two mosques:the venerable Al-Aqsa,
which was built in the eighth century, and the thirteen-hundred-year-old
Dome of the Rock. Its golden dome-the most recognizable symbol of
the city-enshrines the craggy peak of Mt. Moriah, which Jews call
the Foundation Stone and Muslims call es-Sakhra (the Rock). It figures
prominently in the legend of all three religions. It is said to
be the first place God created-the perch He stood on when He formed
the rest of the world. It is also said to be the spot where Adam
was made, and where Cain killed Abel. Jews believe that it is where
Abraham brought his son Isaac to be sacrificed. For Muslims, it
was Ishmael-Abraham's other son, and their ancestor-who was intended
to be sacrificed. For Jews, the Mount is the holiest place in the
world, the focus of their prayers, the place where they believe
God lived. Muslims believe that this was the place from which the
prophet Muhammad ascended into Heaven on the back of a winged horse.
Jerusalem was the original direction of Muslim prayers, before Mecca,
and is still a destination for pilgrims. They count it as the third
holiest place in Islam, after Mecca and Medina.
Many conquering
armies have entered the Temple grounds. In Jerusalem's bloody history,
the city has been contested by Assyrians, Babylonians, Egyptians,
Greeks, Romans, Persians, Mongols, Mamluks, Ottomans, Jordanians,
and the British-to name only some of the major invaders and occupiers.
Dayan and his generals were mindful of the shadows they were casting
on history as they broke through the gates of the Haram al-Sharif
to inspect the grounds. They found a typical Arab garden, liberally
planted with trees and flowers and surrounded by religious offices
and schools-a vivid contrast to the stony city outside the walls.
At the southern end of the sanctuary, which covers thirty-five acres,
lies the vast and airy Al-Aqsa mosque, where pigeons fly freely
in a forest of marble columns. Near the center of the Haram, rising
above the trees like a blue-and-gold crown, is the Dome of the Rock,
the oldest building in Islam and perhaps the most beautiful. Here
the Arab love of mystical geometry and intricate ornament has been
given its greatest expression. The structure, which is eight-sided,
may be imagined as three rectangles encompassing a circle. Hushed,
sombre, but almost overwhelmingly sensual, the chamber imbues one
with a sense of religious awe that few holy places in the world
can match. A dozen pillars of marble and porphyry support the great
inner dome. Below it, a wooden balustrade surrounds the Rock. There
is an oblong imprint in the Rock which is said to be the footprint
made by Muhammad when he leaped onto his winged steed, al-Buraq,
and went up into Heaven with the angel Gabriel.
After inspecting
the Haram, Dayan descended to the Western Wall, where he stood with
his soldiers, many of whom were openly sobbing. As long as the Old
City had been in Jordanian hands, Jews were not allowed to pray
at the Wall; and now Dayan himself wrote a prayer and stuck it into
crevices between the great stones, as Jews had done for centuries
after the destruction of the Temple. It read, "May peace descend
on the whole house of Israel." As the first step in achieving
that peace, Dayan ordered the Israeli flag to be taken down from
the Dome.
The capture
of the Old City came at a great price-hundreds of casualties among
the Israeli troops, and many more among the Arabs-but it proved
to be a decisive turning point in relations between Israel and its
neighbors. The political consequences are still being debated, and
will be addressed in the Final Status talks that are yet to begin
with the Palestinians, who want to share Jerusalem as the capital
of two countries. Dayan believed that the capture of the West Bank
and the Sinai were useful only insofar as they could be traded for
peace. Jerusalem, however, was a more complicated issue. Within
days of the conquest, an Arab neighborhood was levelled to make
a plaza in front of the Western Wall. Despite this action, Dayan
sought to preserve some of the Arab character of the Old City. Ten
days after the capture of the Temple Mount, Dayan returned to Al-Aqsa
and sat on the carpet in his stocking feet with the Waqf, the charitable
trust in charge of managing the Mount. There, on his own authority,
Dayan made a momentous gesture. He told the Waqf directors that,
while all of Jerusalem now belonged to Israel, day-to-day control
over the Haram al-Sharif would remain in their hands. Jews would
be allowed to visit the Mount but forbidden to pray. Since then,
the Temple Mount has been an Islamic island in an increasingly Jewish,
and increasingly Orthodox, city-and, as such, it has become a flashpoint
for religious extremists of both faiths.
The taking of
Jerusalem had an electrifying effect in another realm, one that
few of Israel's secular leaders had anticipated. From the moment
that footage of weeping Israeli paratroopers standing at the Western
Wall was televised around the world, millions of Jews and fundamentalist
Christians saw the victory as the divine fulfillment of prophecy,
one that had been expected since the establishment of the State
of Israel, in 1948. For them, the Jewish possession of the Temple
Mount meant that the clock of the apocalypse had begun to tick.
Gershon Salomon, who as a young officer was partially crippled in
1958 when an Israeli tank rolled over him during a battle on the
Golan Heights, has become one of the most well-known advocates of
removing the mosques in order to rebuild the Temple right away.
He recalls being on the Mount on liberation day in 1967 and thinking,
God brought us back onto the Temple Mount to say to all the world,
"Not only do I continue my relationship with Israel, and Jews
continue to be my Chosen People, but I now open up to the fulfillment
of my End Time plans." That is why Dayan's order to strike
the Israeli flag from the Dome of the Rock came as a stunning betrayal.
"I cried tears of pain and sorrow and sadness," recalls
Salomon, who thereupon founded the Temple Mount and Land of Israel
Faithful Movement, which is based in Jerusalem and boasts a worldwide
membership of more than fifteen thousand. "I decided I had
to start a godly campaign for the reliberation of the Temple Mount.
I would give the rest of my life to correct that sinful, terrible
mistake and act which was done by Moshe Dayan."
Forces had been
let loose in the religious world that would prove difficult to contain.
Galvanized by the Israeli victory, Jewish immigrants flooded into
Israel. This influx seemed to be another sign that the Messiah was
soon to come, since the "ingathering" of Jews in the Land
of Israel was a precondition of redemption, according to the Scripture.
New voices of prophecy drew thousands of Jews, even those who had
been quite secular, into messianic cults of the ultra-Orthodox.
The Six-Day
War spurred a rise of fundamentalism in the Arab world as well.
Radical Islam had a ready explanation for its sudden, crushing defeat:
the moral decay of modern, secular Arab society. The confusion and
despair caused by the loss of Jerusalem fuelled a new religious
extremism, and Haram al-Sharif became a symbol of Islamic religious
and political aspirations. Yasir Arafat began to employ images of
the Dome almost as if it were the capitol building of the future
Palestinian state.
In 1967, the
Knesset passed a law guaranteeing each religion access to its holy
sites, but the law said nothing about the conflict posed by sites
that are sacred to more than one religion. The following year the
Israeli Supreme Court, in a ruling that has been upheld several
times, decreed that Jews do have the right to pray on the Mount,
leaving the government in the uncomfortable position of enforcing
a ban based only on its need to maintain public order. To this day,
Jews and Christians can go on the Mount as tourists, but if they
appear to be praying they are subject to removal or arrest.
After the war,
the Israeli Minister for Religious Affairs, Zerah Wahrhaftig, said
that the Temple Mount had been the property of Israel ever since
King David purchased the site from Araunah the Jebusite in 1000
B.C., but that Jews should not take any steps to reclaim it, because
only the Messiah could build the Third Temple. This position was
endorsed by many Jews, particularly the ultra-Orthodox, many of
whom even opposed the establishment of the State of Israel. In their
theology, the rebuilding of the nation, the ingathering of Jews
from exile, and the reestablishment of the Temple were all matters
for the Messiah to handle. For humankind to undertake such things
amounted to "forcing the End." That was the work of Satan.
There were many
prominent Jews, however, who believed that they were already living
in the End Time-the recapture of Jerusalem was evidence enough-and
that Jews must now do their part to prepare the way for the appearance
of the Messiah. Soon after the Six-Day War was over, Shlomo Goren,
who later became the Chief Rabbi of Israel, led a group of fifty
followers onto the Mount, where they fought off Muslim guards and
Israeli police and conducted a prayer service. A week later, the
Chief Rabbinate ordered that signs be placed in front of the gates
saying that no Jews should set foot on the Temple Mount. The reasoning
was that, because Jews are ritually impure, they might accidentally
step on the place where the Holy of Holies once stood. Such a desecration
is punishable by death at the hand of God. This was supposed to
put the Temple Mount theologically off limits-at least, until the
advent of the red heifer.
Despite this
proscription, there have been several serious attempts to blow
up the Muslim holy places. Both Israeli and Islamic authorities
are so concerned about the intentions of Gershon Salomon and other
Temple fanatics that every confrontation has the potential to rage
out of control. In 1990, Salomon led a group of his followers to
the Mount in order to lay a "cornerstone" for the Third
Temple. As many as five thousand Muslims, many of them schoolchildren,
gathered to defend the site. The Israeli authorities, which had
failed to reinforce a police garrison on the Mount, dispatched paramilitary
border guards to control the situation. An armed assault by the
guards left at least seventeen Muslims dead and hundreds wounded.
In September, 1996, the government of the Prime Minister, Benjamin
Netanyahu, authorized the opening of a tunnel that runs beside the
Mount, so that tourists could view the monumental Herodian walls
at the base. Ensuing riots by Muslims and a forceful response by
Israeli troops left eighty people dead. The toll from these incidents
and others is just one measure of the cost of fundamentalism in
a region that increasingly finds itself drawn and quartered by religious
extremists. The mystical concept of sacred space that shrouds the
Temple Mount-and, beyond that, Jerusalem and Israel itself-has for
centuries served as an impenetrable barrier to peace.
Nadav Shragai,
a reporter for the Israeli newspaper Ha'aretz and the author of
a 1995 book, "The Temple Mount Conflict," estimates that
there are about a thousand active supporters of the most radical
Temple Mount movements. No doubt they are heavily infiltrated by
Israeli intelligence, which has long worried that a successful strike
at the mosques would spark a holy war. These activists are a feature
of a larger upheaval in Israeli society, caused by a stunning rise
of religious conservatism and a muscular political involvement of
religious Jews in Israeli politics. "Jewish fundamentalism
of the nationalist branch is mostly the product of the Six-Day War,"
Emmanuel Sivan, a professor of Islamic Studies at Hebrew University,
says. "The fact is that until '67 the national religious camp
was a very moderate Zionist movement. It has turned extremist because
of this apocalyptic vision."
Among Christians,
there was a similar burst of fundamentalist fervor following the
Six-Day War, and unexpected alliances were made between Evangelical
Christians and Jews. Many Americans (forty-six per cent, according
to one poll) believe that the establishment of the nation of Israel
is the fulfillment of prophecy, and this accounts in part for the
unshakable support that Israel has received from the Christian right.
"I know people who fell on their knees and cried out to God
when they heard that Jerusalem was back in Jewish hands," says
David Parsons, who is an attorney with the International Christian
Embassy, in Jerusalem. "It forced Christians to rethink their
views toward Israel, toward Jerusalem, toward prophecy." The
"embassy" is actually an organization that promotes Jewish
causes and raises money for such things as helping Jews immigrate
to Israel. Christians have also helped to fund some of the radical
Temple activists, including Gershon Salomon.
In Christian
theology, the holiness of the Temple was supposed to have been replaced
by the divinity of Christ. Jesus directly challenged Temple life
by overthrowing the money changers' tables and driving out the venders
of sacrificial animals. In doing so, he committed an offense against
the status quo that may have led to his crucifixion. Many Christians
believe that the Jews killed Christ, and that God then allowed the
Temple to be destroyed as a judgment against them.
The motives
behind the modern embrace of Israel by the Christian right are not
always clear. In Genesis 15:18, God gives the land of Israel to
the Jews, and for most fundamentalist Christians that settles the
matter. But Jews also play a tragic role in Evangelical eschatology.
When Jews speak of their Messiah, Evangelicals interpret that to
mean the false Messiah, or the Antichrist. It is the Antichrist,
Evangelicals believe, who will occupy the Third Temple. The Prophet
Jeremiah foretold the tribulation, or "time of Jacob's trouble,"
by which he meant the devastation of Israel. The nation will be
finished off in the apocalyptic meeting between Christ and the Antichrist
at Armageddon, which is also known as Megiddo, an archeological
ruin in northern Israel. Those Jews who survive this catastrophe-only
a hundred and forty-four thousand, according to some interpretations
of the Scripture-will finally turn to Jesus as the true Messiah.
Such refrains are frequently heard in Evangelical churches and on
religious television channels, where Temple fever burns.
Most Evangelicals
believe that the establishment of the State of Israel and the capture
of Jerusalem have cleared the way for these final events. "I
am one of those who believe that the next event on God's calendar
is the rapture of the Church-the coming of Christ to take the Church
to itself," the Reverend Jerry Falwell, another notable defender
of the nation of Israel, says. "I believe there will be a seven-year
tribulation period. It is during that time that the new Temple will
be built. And I believe that, at the end of the seven years of tribulation,
the battle of Armageddon will transpire and the establishment of
the one-thousand-year reign of Christ on Earth will begin."
However, Christians, like Jews, disagree among themselves about
what role they should play in this scenario. Falwell does not endorse
attempts to force the End. "I am not one who believes, as some
Christian Zionists do, that we are here to help usher in the Kingdom,
build the Temple, bring in the red heifer, et cetera, et cetera,
et cetera," he says. Although Falwell maintains that "God
is under no obligation to rapture the Church today," he believes
that "all the prophecies are fulfilled"-including the
ability, through Cable News Network, to communicate instantly throughout
the world. "That is all necessary during the tribulation,"he
says. "For example, two witnesses will be slain on the streets
of Jerusalem-some believe Moses and Elijah, but no one knows-and
the Scripture says that every eye shall behold. And three days later
they shall rise from the dead, rise up from the streets of Jerusalem.
While all the enemies of these witnesses are rejoicing, in a huge
global party, the whole world will watch as they stand up alive,
resurrected from the dead. That couldn't have happened when I was
a child." Because of these portents, Falwell believes that
the Antichrist may be alive now. "He will portray himself as
Christ and that will necessitate his being a Jew."
According to
Clyde Lott, the intent of many Evangelical Christians who are helping
Israel today is to speed along the time when they will be raptured
into Heaven, leaving behind a world in chaos and flames. "It's
very sad, but I would say the interest in the Christian world is
to see the Temple rebuilt from the Antichrist perspective, for the
rapture of the Church, and that's a very selfish point of view,"
Lott says. "The very people that are advocating this are the
ones that are very anti-Semitic in their feelings." Although
Evangelical theology forecasts the destruction of the Jews in the
Last Days, Lott believes that Jews are God's Chosen People and that
the Bible clearly states that God favors those who help Israel.
The Christian
right in the United States has proved to be both a powerful political
lobby for Israel and a substantial source of financial support.
Earlier this year, when Prime Minister Netanyahu came to this country,
Jerry Falwell received him, while the White House did not. Most
Israelis understand the subtext of this alliance, but they are loath
to disclaim it. "Basically, we're a doormat for them to get
to their own eschatological culmination," Rabbi Richman says.
"It's a pretty scary thing, because the whole rapture thing
that is popular in some Evangelical circles, which calls for a fulfillment
of the hard times for Jacob, is essentially an invitation to genocide."
Richman and
Lott disavow any association with Salomon or with other extremists
who would destroy the mosques. They say they don't know how the
Temple will be built, or when. Lott sees his own mission as part
of a divine promise God made to Israel (in Isaiah 30:23) that one
day its land would be restored and cattle would graze "in large
pastures" there. "In God's timing, we know that all Bible
prophecy will be fulfilled, and, if God chooses to use the Numbers
19 red heifer from that standpoint, that's up to God," Lott
says. "Our calling is simply to begin the actual bringing in
of the red cow, and at the same time begin to work, as much as Christian
people possibly can, with the Jewish people for this restoration."
Richman spent
his childhood in Massachusetts, and he knew very little about the
Deep South or Pentecostalism. On Richman's first trip to Mississippi,
in 1994, Lott booked the community center in Canton for a town meeting
about the red heifer. Richman was nervous. More than three hundred
people showed up, filling all the available chairs and standing
against the back wall and the sides of the room. Many of them had
never seen an Orthodox Jew. "I look the part," Richman
admits. He wears a curly beard and rose-tinted oval glasses. Dangling
below the hem of his suit jacket are blue zizith-the ritual fringes
that are meant to remind Orthodox Jews of the Lord's commandments.
One man in the audience pointed to the knitted kipa on Richman's
head and asked, in apparent seriousness, if he wore it to hide his
horns.
Richman found
the audience surprisingly warm and well versed in the Bible, however,
even in obscure passages that had to do with the building of the
Temple. Soon after that, he and Lott began the first of a series
of barnstorming tours through Evangelical churches, mainly in the
Deep South. Lott would introduce Richman, who would speak about
the Temple, and then an offering would be taken up to support their
work. "The services are-shall I say-interactive," Richman
says. "It's not like someone gives an address and everyone
sits there like statues. People call out and say 'Amen.' Sometimes
the preacher would try to quiet them down, and I'd say, 'No, let
everyone be themselves.' The people are a lot warmer and less jaded
than people in the North. I found a lot of openness and interest
in what I had to say. I found that we share many of the same values-the
family, and what they call 'holiness,' and a mode of worship that
emphasizes joy."
For Christians,
building the Temple is important only in that it raises the curtain
on the apocalypse. Richman explains that the Temple is critical
to Jews: "We have this concept that we have six hundred and
thirteen commandments to fulfill, and one-third of those commandments
are dependent in some way on the Temple for their fulfillment."
Many of these Temple laws involve the sacrifice of animals. For
Jews in the ancient world, animal sacrifice was a means of achieving
the purity that was essential in relating to God. A person can be
defiled by even indirect contact with death-for instance, through
the ground itself, which harbors the dead. Therefore, no one who
walks on the ground is sufficiently holy to enter the Temple precincts.
So the absence of a red heifer made the rebuilding of the Temple
a moot point for Orthodox Jews-and therefore for Christians as well.
For as long
as there have been archeologists, there has been a hunger to excavate
the Mount in order to establish the exact location of the First
Temple, and also to find some of the treasures it is supposed to
harbor. The subsurface of the Mount is interlaced with tunnels and
cisterns and legendary secret chambers, which may hide the Ark of
the Covenant with the tablets of the Ten Commandments, which have
been lost since the destruction of the First Temple. (Lott says
that Richman told him that these objects were never actually lost-that
they have been stored under the Mount, awaiting the reconstruction
of the Temple.) On several occasions, archeologists and Jewish religious
leaders have conducted unauthorized digs under the Mount, which
have been met with outraged responses on the part of Islamic authorities.
Because no one
can say definitively where on the Mount the Temple stood, most observant
Jews have obeyed the rabbinical proscription against going onto
the Mount; however, it is well known that Herod built up the periphery
of the Mount when he enlarged the Temple, and for that reason it
is thought by many Jews to be safe to walk on.
Every Tuesday,
just as the Al-Aqsa mosque is emptying of worshippers for the noon
prayers, Rabbi Yosef Elboim arrives at the Maghariba Gate. A small,
wiry man with a white beard and scraggly earlocks, he wears a black
frock coat, and a homburg rides insecurely on the back of his head.
As Elboim changes from his street shoes into a pair of slippers,
guards begin to talk nervously on their walkie-talkies. "Make
it quick," one tells him.
"When I
was thirteen, the Six-Day War took place," Elboim said, as
he began his weekly stroll around the perimeter of the Haram al-Sharif.
"I heard on the radio that the Temple Mount had been captured,
and I was very excited. I was sure that all the government bodies
were gathered together with the rabbis, planning how and when to
build the Temple. A year later, I woke up to the reality of betrayal.
I set about trying to find other people who were interested and
who cared." The Rabbi walked inside a small cordon of security
police. Some Arab children in school uniform coming out of an Islamic
school looked at him in amazement. There are several groups of Jews
who make a point of defying the rabbinical ban against Jews walking
on the Temple Mount, but, unlike Elboim, they are not ultra-Orthodox,
so his presence here is all the more jarring.
For a while,
Elboim continued, he joined forces with Gershon Salomon, but then
he formed his own organization, Tnua Lechinun Hamikdash (Movement
for Establishment of the Temple). "We started by making holy
vessels and ritual garments worn by the priests, so that we could
have all this ready for when the time comes," Elboim said.
Now his organization has announced a controversial new project:
a home for boys who will become cohanim-members of the priestly
caste who ran the Temple. "During the time of the Temple, the
ashes of the red heifer were kept in containers, so when the priests
saw they were running out of ashes they would use up the old ones
and make some more. But today we don't have any 'leftovers.' So
it's important to take children, even before they are born, and
bring them up in a place where there is no chance for them to come
into contact with the dead." During the era of the Second Temple,
boy priests were raised in compounds built on solid bedrock, out
of the range of any possible gravesites.
Elboim claims
that he has already received offers from four families to donate
their future children to his effort, but he expects to need at least
nineteen, in part so that the boys will have companionship, but
also because there are more than seventy blemishes that can disqualify
a boy from becoming a priest. He says that a Jewish settlement near
Jerusalem is willing to build a special enclosure for the priestly
boys so that they will never have to set foot on the ground. There
will be an elevated courtyard where they can play. According to
Ha'aretz, some of the other people involved with Elboim's plan are
former members of Kach, an outlawed far-right religious party. The
boys will not be permitted to leave the compound until their bar
mitzvah, at the age of thirteen, at which time, according to tradition,
they will become adults and are old enough to slaughter and prepare
the ashes of a red heifer. In response to the suggestions that have
appeared in the press that such treatment constitutes child abuse,
Elboim points out that the boys will not be unattended-they will
be able to receive family and visitors, who have undergone purification
in a mikvah, or ritual bath, and put on special clothing, and they
will be educated and allowed to play with computers. Their lives
would be no worse than that of Christian or Buddhist monks, or certain
child athletes, Elboim contends. There would be no point in having
a red heifer, Elboim believes, without a priestly caste to prepare
the sacrifice.
In August, 1996,
a surprising development occurred: another red calf was born, this
time in Israel, on a farm outside Haifa run by a religious high
school. "I had some doubts about it from the very beginning,"
says Rabbi Shmaria Shore, whose son came running to him with the
news of the birth. "But I saw that she was very red, and I
couldn't see hairs of any other color, so Iended up contacting some
rabbinical authorities, and some people from Jerusalem eventually
came." The rabbis examined the calf, which Shore had named
Tslil, a name that means a musical note, but which he translated
as Melody.
To Shore's amazement,
the rabbis pronounced Melody a qualified red heifer, despite the
fact that he had begun to notice a few stray white hairs around
her tail and udder, and her eyebrows, which had started out red,
had turned black. Also, the calf would not qualify as a heifer for
two years, and by then many other imperfections might come to light.
"I decided to play along, in order to downplay it," he
says now. The rabbis carried the news of the miraculous birth back
to Jerusalem, and soon a pilgrimage of Orthodox Jews and international
press seeking "the Holy Heifer from Haifa" began turning
up in the small religious community of Kfar Hasidim, where Melody
now resided under armed guard. No red heifer, it was said, had been
born in Israel since the destruction of the Temple. "It is
written that it is the tenth red heifer that the Messiah will discover,
and here we have the tenth heifer," one of the rabbis said
on Israel Radio.
Muslims and
a majority of Jews reacted in alarm. A columnist for Ha'aretz called
for the cow to be shot immediately and "every molecule"
destroyed. "The potential harm from this heifer is far greater
than the destructive properties of a regular terrorist bomb,"
David Landau wrote. Even Rabbi Shore cautioned that the time had
not come to rebuild the Temple. But Melody was creating her own
reality. Jewish longing for the Temple, Christian hopes for the
rapture, and Muslim paranoia about the destruction of the mosques
were being stirred to an apocalyptic boil.
"In any case, she solved the problem herself by growing a white
tail," Rabbi Shore says now. No longer kosher, Melody has rejoined
the herd, but she is pregnant, Shore says, by a "reddish"
bull.
The Reverend
Lott had been suspicious of Melody's qualifications, but the episode
alerted him and Rabbi Richman to the sensational political consequences
of their project. Nevertheless, on the eve of the ninth day of the
Hebrew month of Av, in 1997-coincidentally, the day on which the
destruction of both the First and Second Temples is commemorated-Lott,
Richman, and a group of West Bank settlers reached an agreement
to provide land to raise red cattle. Lott and Richman are partners,
but, in the event that Lott is raptured with the Church, Richman
and the settlers will assume entire control of the operation. This
December, they are planning to ship five hundred pregnant cows to
the Jordan Valley. The cattle are being bred in Nebraska, on a three-thousand-acre
spread devoted to Red Angus. There seems little doubt that a red
heifer that meets all the Halakic criteria will soon be born in
Israel, possibly early next year. The land that Lott has found is
in the occupied West Bank-"some of the most hotly contested
land in the world," he admitted recently to a revival audience
in Gulf Shores, Alabama. "It's going to require feedlots, slaughterhouses-a
whole economy." He will also ship frozen embryos from Dixie
and other donor cows, along with select sperm, to be held in safekeeping
until after the tribulation. According to Lott, his efforts will
ensure that "in the first one or two or three decades of the
millennial reign Israel will be able to go into the tanks, pull
out those frozen embryos, and place them in cows. And in one generation,
whatever they lost in the tribulation, they will have the very best
cows on the face of the earth.... She will be able to get the rest
of the world back on its feet again, agriculturally, from a livestock
point of view."
Jerusalem makes
a cult of holiness, one that fuels the passion and yearning of millions
for a personal encounter with God. "In the Old Testament, time
and time again it says this is God's house, this is where God dwells,"
says Father Jerome Murphy-O'Connor, a professor of New Testament
at the École Biblique et École Archéologique
Française, in Jerusalem. "The assumption was that God's
power and protection were most efficacious in this place. Hence
the importance of pilgrimage to Jerusalem, pilgrimage to the Temple."
For centuries, believers have streamed into the city in order to
bathe in this sense of divinity and to marvel at the site that all
three religions believe will be the place of the Last Judgment.
On that day, both Evangelical Christians and Orthodox Jews expect
their Messiah to stride down from the Mount of Olives and burst
through the Golden Gate. Many Muslims believe that the Ka'aba-the
holiest place in Mecca-will be transported to Jerusalem, and that
all the dead will meet again in the streets of the city. As long
as such mythologies are taken literally, the struggle for Jerusalem
and the Temple Mount will never end. The religious carnage that
has marked every era of this maddened city will continue, because
whoever controls Jerusalem controls access to the sacred places.
It is a way of owning God.
|